Proposed Legislation Would Mandate
Aging Lawmakers Raise Fitness Questions
With nearly 120 U.S. lawmakers aged 70 or older, concerns about mental fitness are growing.
Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez proposed cognitive testing to “determine if any member suffers from serious cognitive issues,” but the idea was rejected.
Still, public trust is wavering.
Debate Over Testing
Supporters say tests could restore confidence, while critics argue they may violate rights or be misused.
“A constitutional amendment would be required,” making mandatory testing unlikely.
Global Standards & Legal Limits
Few countries test leaders routinely. In Singapore and Vatican City, leaders must be of “sound mind,” but regular checks are rare.
In the U.S., the Constitution limits options, and Congress rarely expels members for incapacity.
Challenges and Alternatives
Tests like the MMSE or MoCA aren’t suited for officeholders.
Transparency and medical reviews when concerns arise may be more realistic ways to ensure leaders are fit to serve.
